Showing posts with label Exercise 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Exercise 4. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 5, 2014

Expert-/heuristic evaluation debriefing

In the following we elaborate on the steps and measures we took in order to incorporate the feedback, which we received during the expert-evaluation.

Questions

1) Omitted: due to the fact that our design is not subject to budget restriction and as we strongly believe that an implementation of the system at a reasonable-price is feasible.
2) Incorporated: we already thought of security concerns regarding the panels before, and decided to use safety glass plates instead of touch screens.
3) Incorporated: in favour of our target group we decided that playing the game as a couple is sufficient.
4) Incorporated: we converted the touch screen into a big panel "button", as suggested.
5) Omitted:  we decided against levels.
6) Incorporated: after the feedback we defined 30s. as the time for one round and tried it out during the user testing, which turned out to be sufficient.
7) Omitted: we could not identify any suitable use case for a moving floor.
8) Incorporated: we added an introduction (i.e.; a voice recording) at the beginning of the game.
9) Incorporated: we added voice feedback (e.g.; "perfect, nästa", "rätt", "fel", ...)
10) Considered: a handicapped person will need assistance from an adult.
11) Incorporated: we did, a rope from the top not make a final decision how the monkey climbs the tree.
12) Omitted: dependent on question no. 11, and we decided against the monkey falling of the tree at the end. 

Suggestions

All suggestions were directly incorporated into our design and prototype.

Friday, October 10, 2014

Expert-/heuristic evaluation

This post gives a brief summary of the expert-evaluation, which was conducted according to the schema provided in the exercise slides.

Questions

During the evaluation the following questions were raised by the other team: 
  1. The proposed design could be expensive! 
  2. Safety concerns regarding the screens. 
  3. What if large groups use the solution? primary / secondary functions 
  4. Touch panels can be worn out! 
  5. Are there levels? user group 
  6. What about the speed of the game? 
  7. Does the floor move? 
  8. How will someone understand the principles of the game? 
  9. How should the player know how to interact? 
  10. What about handicap people? primary / secondary functions 
  11. How does the monkey move up the tree? 
  12. Does the monkey drop at some point?

Suggestions

The other team made the following suggestions (the number in the bracket is the question which is answered by the suggestion): 
  1. Use a button instead of panels, which is more affordable (1,2,4) design/composition 
  2. Speakers should be in the tree design/composition 
  3. There should be an introduction before the game (8,9) design/composition

General  

Besides the questions and suggestions it was clear to the other group for whom we designed the game. However, they were concerned with whether children would understand how to interact with the game (the feeling / interaction / help). Nonetheless, they agreed that the kids would probably stay and return if the game is challenging enough.