Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Group meeting: Interview analyse.

Yesterday we went to the museum to conduct our interviews for the design research. We followed the three rules of Rick E. Robinson, "You go to them", "You talk to them" and "You write stuff down", meaning we went directly to our users in the environment where our solution will be in place. 

Today we gathered again to look through the interviews together as a group and see if we could find any phenomena or patterns. We decided the best way would be to just go through the questions one by one and let everyone tell what answers they got. If more of us got the same answer to a question it can be seen as a pattern and of course be more important than the answers that only occurred once. Some questions are left out as the answers were either screening questions or had irrelevant answers. The full set of questions can be found in this post:

http://swedishblondies.blogspot.se/2014/09/group-meeting-on-922-creating-moderator.html


2) How old are you?
Our subgroup is children of the age of 7-12 but it is not very strict at this point and because the lack of children to interview we went a bit broader. It also isn't trivial to guess the age before starting the interview. The actual range landed at 5-13 in our interviews. But since there is a huge difference between a 5 year old and a 13 year old we also discussed splitting our subgroup into two personas, one younger and one older.

4) How often do you go to museums?
The answer varied, but the average was somewhere around 3-5 times a year.

5) Do you normally enjoy going to museums?

Everyone we asked said they enjoyed the visit. Considering the museum we went to is aimed at children that was not too surprising. However we also wondered whether even if they did not enjoy the visit they would have said so standing next to their parents (and us).

6) What was the best museum you've been to? Why?
We got a lot of different answers, but when asked why a certain museum was their favorite we noticed a pattern that they had a lot of interaction.

7) Do you like interacting with other people while at a museum?
The big majority said they would rather stick to the people they came with than interacting with other people at the museum. Considering one of our early brainstorming ideas was to make a game where you compete against other groups this was important for us to know.

9) How can you make the museum more fun?
There were not many ideas of how to make the museum more fun. But it was a hard questions and not something we expected a lot of answers from.

10) Why did you visit the museum?

A lot of the people choose this museum because they had been here before, but said it is big enough for you to learn something new every time. Some also said they had not been able to see everything last time because it is so big, and now they wanted to see the rest. Some also mentioned the human body exhibit as a reason for coming.

11) What are you hoping to get out of the experience?

A lot of people said they came hoping to learn stuff in a fun environment. The human body exhibition was also mentioned again with people having expectations to have fun there.

12) What are you hoping to learn?

Once again the human body exhibition was mentioned by several people. Wanting to learn about it in a fun and experimental environment. It seems to be the most popular thing in the museum at the moment.

2) What was the worst part of your visit?
People did not have much bad to say about their visit, but two things were mentioned. One was that the dinosaur exhibit was closed which disappointed a lot of people (though not really relevant to our project). They also noted a big difference between the exhibitions. Some had a lot of interactive parts to them (as mentioned in our individual state of art analyses), where as others had none at all. It was suggested to add more interactions to the ones that were missing it to make them as fun as the rest.

3) What was the best part of your visit?
The two big winners here was again the human body, as well as the Cosmonova movie.

4) What did you learn?
Most children could not come up with anything particular they had learned during the visit.  However a few mentioned that the Cosmonova movie had been a good tool of learning, and it was the only learning experience mentioned.

Having gone through the interviews one problem occurred to us. Everyone we talked to was very positive, either because they were too shy to be honest, or because they actually loved it all. However since we are looking for a problem to solve, we were hoping to have some critic that we could focus on improving.

We did discuss the idea one guest gave us, to update the parts of the museum that were missing interactive parts. By gathering information from our subgroup and their thoughts on the already existing solutions, it would help us to create our own solution. We could then implement this solution in one of the exhibitions that are currently lacking any interaction to make those as popular as the human body exhibition that had a lot of interaction and was by far the most popular exhibition.

Map of the museum




Group meeting: State-of-the-Art analyse.

We all analyzed technical parts of different exhibits. We noticed that in the older exhibits the technical aspects were quite outdated, slow, and even buggy. Many of the technical aspects of the different exhibits took the form of games, videos, or activities on a touch screen. Some of them were not very fun because they were slow or had way too many words. Our target group is children aged 7-12, and lots of words will not catch and hold their attention. When technology is slow, children (and most people in general) lose patience and move onto the next part of the exhibit.

We did see a couple good examples as well. We analyzed a game with 3D mushrooms and a guessing game that went along with it. We noticed that children also like playing with and seeing large objects in the museums. Another good example was one of the interactive touch screens in The Human Animal exhibit. The game was quick, challenging, and simple to use.

We found that overall, kids seemed to react best to instant feedback games. Right now we see that a lot technical parts of the older exhibits need to be updated, but we would rather come up with a brand new idea to improve the museum experience.

State-of-the-Art Analysis - Thomas Ziegelbecker

At the moment the museum of our choice already offers ways of interaction, for instance: 
  • A wall with pictures of animals with a control panel, where one can highlight a certain animal by hitting a button with the corresponding name. 
  • A map where one can see the population spread, starting from Africa
  • Horses that kids can feed with small fake bread
  • Games to match cans with words (animals) 
  • Listening to sounds
  • TouchTable
During the observations we used the following means to draw our conclusions:
  • Fly on the wall
  • Qualitative Interviews 

Conclusions from the observations
The majority of devices/interfaces in the museum were screens, which are either controlled by touch or some kind of a roller ball in combination with buttons. The response time of the latter was often perceived as very slow, which made the interaction rather cumbersome. Most of the times the screens were used for quizes, which could be described as text heavy. Thus, I believe most of them are not really suitable for kids. Kids rarely stopped in front of plates in order to read text, but only when there is some kind of interaction.

Conclusions from the interviews
Kids remember two parts of the exhibition the most, first the Dinosaurs, and second the "The human animal". The reason for that might be because the former shows impressive huge bones and kids usually love dinosaur, and the latter offers the most interactions in the whole museum (i.e. games, explorative things to touch and modify). Another finding is that there is no form of interaction among visitors at all. Only a few kids actually picked the museum for the visit, instead their parents brought them in order to learn something, thus, the main goal is to educate kids  

State-of-the-Art Analysis - Jessie Pease + Body Language Exhibit

As many of my colleagues have mentioned, the Natural History Museum does a pretty good job of including interactive elements into the exhibits. Many of those interactive elements are touch screens with step-by-step quizzes, videos, or games to play that teach the visitors about the subject in that exhibit. 

I am analyzing one of those touch screens from The Human Animal exhibit. This exhibit is relatively new and very interactive. The entire time we were there, children were running around and playing with the different parts of the exhibit. The specific touch screen I looked at and played with for a while is called "Body Language." 

Body Language was a quiz that tested the visitor's ability to recognize different types of body language by just looking at a solid human cartoon character make different expressions. We did not see the face. We only saw how the body moved. From there, we got 3 choices of different expressions the human might be feeling considering the situation described. One you chose the right answer, it congratulated you, and you moved onto the next question. As the game went on, it got more difficult. Instead of seeing an entire human outline, we eventually only got to see a dotted outline of the body. 

The game was fun, interactive, and challenging. The test got more difficult as it went on which added a larger challenge and made me want to continue playing the game. There was no sound, so the game only required the use of 2 senses: touch and sight. 

State-of-the-Art Analysis - Alex Hoffmann

I chose a digital table for the analysis because it was one of the newest pieces of technology in the museum and comes close to what we might design.

The table was located in the arctic area. It was a large touch controlled display, showing information about the animals living in the arctic region. The Information was shown on Cards that had a picture on one side and a short text about that animal on the back. I could turn, drag and flip the cards fairly easy and the controls where quite intuitive.
A problem was the delay between an input and the reaction. Another problem was that is wasn't clear what actions you could perform. I tried out everything that i usually can do with touch controlled interfaces, but sometimes it worked, sometimes not. Buttons haven't been clearly marked so you did not know where you can push something.
But the table is good for children because they can drag around stuff and have pictures of animals. It is fun to play around and the children see what the animals look like.
The information on the back would be more for the parents to explain to them.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

State-of-the-Art Analysis - Johan Lindeberg: the mollusk (blötdjur) room.

What I picked to call "The mollusk room" is a smaller area that you pass through in the museum. As you enter the room, there's a lot of information everywhere. Stuffed animals in glass cabinets in the middle of the room, combined with signs giving some information about the animal, paintings and text on all the walls. In the room you will learn about different sea creatures such as mollusk (blötdjur) and echinoderms (tagghudingar), and how to differentiate between them.

As you enter the room, to your right, a big drawing is painted with all the different creatures, and what species they belong to. Right under this there is a display where you can play a game. At first glance I thought it was a touch display, but to navigate you had to use a rolling-ball as a mouse, and buttons to click. You had to tell which of the animals was not a mollusk. The game and the feedback from it was quite slow, as you clicked an answer it took at least 5-10 seconds before you could click again, while information about the animal you clicked, and whether or not its a mollusk, was displayed.

There were three more screens like this placed in the room, all geared towards learning more about the creatures displayed in the room. All of them used the same navigation, and was quite slow and outdated compared to many other parts of the museum.

There were no people at all in this room as we walked by, while in most other rooms there were at least a few.

State-of-the-Art Analysis - Petter Janse

There was a lot of things you could interact with at the museum. Both technical solutions, often presented on a computer with touch screen, and more old things, such as pressing a button to turn on the light behind a portrait of the correct item matching the name of the button. It also varied from just passive learning, pressing a button to hear the sound of an animal, to more active learning such as learning games or quizzes. But what actually caught my attention was the fact that I saw no two identical solutions in the whole museum. Instead I saw over 20 (and surely missing some) different ones. Even when switching floor and exhibit they would not bring back an already used one.

From a user view I think there are both pros and cons of this. While a lot of the children we interviewed complemented the variety of things, if one of them was really popular why not use it again in a different exhibit? If we would have had more time I would have liked to make a more thoroughly investigation on which one was more popular among our subgroup. It would have really helped us to understand what they were looking for.

In the end I choose to do my analyze on a less modern (no touch pads) , active game. I felt it was a simply solution but still perfect for both a big age range as well as working both when alone or as a duo/group. The fact that there were not a lot of text to read makes me think our subgroup of children is more likely to use it. For a lot of the other solutions you would get fed a lot of text, which seemed to scare away the younger children.

The way it worked was you stepped up to a window where you could see 10 different mushrooms. Then as you pressed start they would turn around to reveal mushrooms but together with the names now (and in different positions so that you are not only memorizing the order). Now you had about a minute to learn the names of the mushrooms before they turned around again to only show the mushrooms. Then your task was to match the mushrooms with their correct name by pressing the buttons listed as 1-10.

The pros of this solution is as I said previously that it works well on a variety of people. It was simple enough to understand for both children as well as older people who might not be have the technical knowledge to use a touch screen. I also liked the fact that you could see actual mushrooms, and not just pictures of them as with most touch screen solutions. Again its hard to tell what our subgroup really does prefer, real items or a touch screen environment, since we did not investigate this during our time there.

The downside of this game was that it took quite some time, both with the waiting while you try to memorize the mushrooms as well as the answering process where you have to stop and think for each of the 10 mushrooms. In a busy day with a lot of people passing by only one person/group in every five minute or so would be able to use it. Other than that I could see no problems with it and I could easily have seen it be replicated for other exhibits, for example doing it with insects.